Best Ways to Build Better Habits & Break Bad Ones | James Clear
These notes were generated by AI and may contain inaccuracies.
Habits are solutions to recurring problems in our environment. Example: After a long day of work, feeling exhausted (recurring problem), solutions include: going for a 30-minute run, playing video games for 30 minutes, or smoking a cigarette. All solve the same core problem.
By age 20, 25, or 28, many solutions are inherited from parents, friends, or early life experiences. Realizing these may not be optimal makes it your responsibility to find better ways.
Welcome to Huberman Lab podcast discussing science and science-based tools for everyday life. Host: Andrew Huberman, professor of neurobiology and ophthalmology at Stanford School of Medicine.
Guest: James Clear, author of Atomic Habits, foremost expert on building rock-solid habits for physical/mental health, work, and relationships.
Discussion: How to build habits and break bad ones quickly and durably. Realistic conversation, minimal clichés like SMART goals (specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, time-bound), but includes some. Emphasizes real-world examples.
James Clear has extensively studied data on habit formation and breaking.
Everyone has habits to build or break. Behavioral change starts with desire but requires a personalized system to stick.
James provides depth of knowledge, generosity, clarity; conversation filled with applicable tools.
Separate from Huberman's Stanford roles; zero-cost science info to public. Episode includes sponsors.
Common habits: exercise (most common New Year's resolution), health/fitness, productivity, creativity (writing, music, painting).
More interesting: Themes making habits stick or fail.
Example: Trainer's class—8 signed up, rainy day, only 2 came. Small edge: Tolerate 5-10 minutes of discomfort (getting ready in rain). Workout same as always.
Biggest lesson from readers: Magic of starting—master 5-minute or 30-second window. Boil habit problems to: (1) easier to start (overcome procrastination), (2) sticking with it (which means getting started each time).
Atomic Habits sold 25 million copies; key lesson: Make it easy to start (scale down, optimize environment, better strategy, involve others) leads to success. Avoid big ambitious plans, doing too much at once.
Create thin edge of wedge: Segment habit (write one word/sentence), find optimal times/environments.
Human flaw: Knowing what to do but looping without action.
Four Laws of Behavior Change (to make habit stick):
- Make it obvious (visual/easy to notice, prime environment).
- Make it attractive (fun/appealing).
- Make it easy (convenient, frictionless, scale down, simplify steps).
- Make it satisfying (pleasure/reward/positive emotion).
Many ways for each law; provides full toolkit (screwdriver, wrench, hammer)—choose what fits.
Make it obvious examples:
- Audit spaces (office, living room, kitchen): What behaviors obvious/easy? Redesign to encourage priorities.
- Run: Set shoes/clothes out night before; some sleep in running clothes.
- Healthy eating: Nuts on counter, not chips.
- Guitar practice: Place on stand in living room (passes 30x/day) vs. closet.
Glucose key for body/brain function, mood, energy, tenacity/willpower. Lingo tracks real-time glucose impact from foods/actions. Spikes/crashes cause fog, fatigue, irritability, hunger. Individual responses vary. Helps build habits for metabolic health. Huberman uses: Foods, timing, post-meal walks. 10% off 4-week plan for US listeners at hellolingo.com/huberman (18+, not on insulin, not for diagnosis).
Wealthfront for saving/investing amid market chaos. Huberman uses nearly decade: 3.25% APY cash account, instant no-fee withdrawals 24/7, seamless to portfolios. New clients: +0.65% boost (3.9% variable APY on $150K, 3 months). wealthfront.com/huberman. >1M users.
Environment overlooked. Example: Advice for comfortable writing chair vs. Steven Pressfield (The War of Art) prefers uncomfortable chair (former Marine). Comfortable couch favors lounging.
Huberman: Best writing on planes (middle seat, pissed off energy). Suboptimal → channel into productivity; perfection → creature comforts.
James: Mental shift to use suboptimal situations is key skill.
James's writing routines varied: Parents' couch, car passenger seat, desk. No single place.
Habits have seasons; adjust as life changes. Don't view change as failure.
James's writing evolution:
- Years 1-3: jamesclear.com, 2,000-word articles Mon/Thu (20 hrs each, 40-hr week), built audience/book deal.
- Years 4-6: Book writing (Atomic Habits), no articles.
- Last 5 years: Weekly 2-hr newsletter, 3M readers/week.
Fitness: Powerlifting/Olympic (4-5x/week), then 2x/week, now 4x/week.
Give permission for habits to adapt; flexibility key to long-term success.
Mental toughness: Not "grind no matter what," but adaptability. Consistency is adaptability.
- Short time → short version.
- Low energy → easy version. Show up, avoid zeros; something > nothing.
Bad days > good days: Bad workouts (20 min squats) count more (no zero). Baseline: What stick on bad days? Ramp up good days.
Optimization: For current moment, not ideal. Over-the-counter stimulants/tutorials lead to chasing perfect flow; sub-optimal feels failure.
Consistency enlarges ability: Builds capacity, skills, strength for harder things. Edge gained on non-optimal days (everyone does easy days).
Consistency raises ceiling on performance. Anyone can do minimal (e.g., one sentence/day). Grind = showing up repeatedly, elevates flow/optimal possibility.
Don't knock flow (Steven Kotler, Csikszentmihalyi); but pursuit makes grind seem failure. Grind: Simplified showing up.
Mastering showing up raises the baseline for failure or poor performance, leading to overall improvement.
Reader Mitch from Atomic Habits had a rule: no longer than five minutes at the gym. He'd drive there, do half an exercise, and leave. This mastered showing up four days a week, becoming the type of person who goes to the gym.
- Inversion of common approach: Most seek perfection first (perfect diet, workout, sales strategy) before starting.
- Quote from Ed Latimore: > "The heaviest weight at the gym is the front door."
- Hardest step is the first movement.
- After six weeks, Mitch extended workouts naturally.
- Better than perfectionism leading to abandonment (e.g., "If I can't run 4 days or workout 45 minutes, why bother?")
- Every showing up matters.
Habits are brain learning new behaviors through practice. You improve at anything practiced daily.
- Not claiming NBA level from basketball practice, but personal improvement.
- Every skill (cutting tomato, playing instrument, brushing teeth) learned via practice.
View habits through learning and neuroplasticity (self-directed adaptive plasticity).
- Brain learns habits constantly, controlled or not.
- Key question: Not if you'll gain habits, but if you can design them (self-directed).
Types of Plasticity
- Developmental plasticity: Passive, experience-shaped, robust in kids (window closes ~25 for accent-free languages; harder after 15-20-25, possible later with effort).
- Self-directed:
- Explorative (e.g., figuring out painting without set goal).
- Instructional plasticity (self-directed adaptive instructional plasticity): Correct answers exist (e.g., free throw from spot, word pronunciation).
Mitch unconsciously chunked: Right answer was getting in the door, prerequisite to workout. Avoids learning 50-1000 things at once.
Chunking aligns with neuroscience: Learn right answers, stack them.
People oversimplify but miss steps to gym:
- Which gym? Time (before/after work, commute)? Drive separately? Water bottle (friction if forgotten, no fountains)? Clothes clean?
- Mastering start crosses thresholds consistently, then optimize workout.
Idea: Effort becomes reward (holy grail, masochistic tones).
Story: Ex-girlfriend (Eastern Canada, hearty, grad degree) said, > "Flow, don't fight."
- She flowed into activities; he pushed despite enjoyment.
- Not always (e.g., her fisherman family: early cold mornings).
Question: Toggle flow and fight? Limit "gas pedal" time; flow automatic parts to fight barriers.
Drive: Dissatisfaction vs. Encoded Growth
James wrestled: Must dissatisfaction (gap between current and desired) drive?
- Acorn-to-oak analogy: Grows without berating self for not being full tree yet. Grows because encoded to (its nature, strengths light up, feel alive).
- Healthiest: Flow into encoded strengths without dissatisfaction.
Effort Becomes Reward Over Time
Rarely immediate; builds (e.g., 15-20 years training: Now enjoys workout feel during sets, not just outcomes/health/looks/after).
Identity-based habits:
- Each workout casts vote for athlete/non-misser identity.
- Reinforces desired identity, feels good.
- Start with: Who do I wish to become? Habits reinforce identity?
- Every action = vote (20min study = studious; hour basketball = player).
- Small individually; collective (3-6-12 months) crosses threshold: Pride in identity → fight to maintain.
- Flips: Do habit because "this is who I am" (runner runs sans marathon).
Friction motivates (Huberman: postdoc lab competition = arms race, new tools, timely problems; anxiety healthy, breakthroughs).
- Science risks: Scooped after years (reset students/postdocs).
- Find assured corners, but competition raises game.
- Not forever; flow sounds nice.
Enjoy exercise in moment (rare; most say "afterwards"; both do during).
- Gift earned.
- Both flow/fight needed; resist always-one-or-other.
Stakes help care (James: Orthopedic internship, wrote 60-page Word doc on habits → public for stakes/feedback → jamesclear.com → Atomic Habits).
Undergrad biomechanics/business (no psych/neuro degree).
- Friend: Become expert by writing weekly.
- Wrote 2 articles/week for 3 years (~150 on habits) → learned, public criticism improved.
- Triangulated decent ideas.
Examples: Derek (More Plates More Dates) superb fitness/health content sans formal training; reads meticulously.
Competence vs. credentials: Wrong sentence matters; right ideas + no degree = fine.
- Midwest practicality resonates (ivory tower out-of-touch).
- Scientists read papers; merge great, no competition.
Tell self: Pain good, getting better.
Exercise templates:
- Resistance training pump: Visual/sensory future evidence (if recover/nutrition right).
- Running hill/vest: Lungs burn, vomit-feel; no in-moment faster feel (tell self: Easier next time).
Cognitive parallels:
- Groove (writing/podcast prep finding papers) = pump (heading someplace).
- Brick wall pain = hill; tell self: Brain learns from friction/failure (not performance; changes only if must).
Writing complaints: Hard = why it works.
- Gym: Weights heavy → stronger.
- Writing: Hard → thinking/clarifying.
- Friction/tension necessary for growth.
- Tell better story: Painful = part of growing.
Previsualization beforehand helps feed the process of showing up. Practice with kids by imagining what a good day looks like. Example with son starting preschool: first two days had difficult drop-offs with crying. On third day, during breakfast, reminded him of positives—you like preschool, your teachers, snack time, glue sticks and crayons activity, then playground after school. Emphasized positive parts of the upcoming experience to create a story of a good day unfolding. Increased odds of good drop-off, and it worked that day.
Sounds like a great day.
Post-Activity Rehearsal of Positives
Huberman: Played baseball through college. At end of each season, sat with dad on back deck replaying good parts—best games, wins, best plays. Emphasized wins to finish season feeling good, even if not the best player, building momentum into next season.
Core question for visualizing ahead or rehearsing afterward: what are you emphasizing?
Two-Page Exercise: Positive vs Negative Stories
Exercise: Take two pieces of paper. Rule: nothing false, must be true.
- First page: negative story of last year—all bad things, what didn't go your way.
- Second page: positive story of last year—all wins, things that worked well, best days.
Both true, no lies. Question: which one do you emphasize each day? What story do you carry into next experience?
As long as not ignoring reality or truth to manage/face, always tell yourself the more empowering story that inspires/empowers/positivizes. Increases odds of showing up, positions better for high performance and kinder actions.
Mental rehearsal puts you in better position for good day and high performance.
Huberman takes AG1 for over a decade since 2012. Highest quality, most comprehensive foundational nutritional supplement: vitamins, minerals, probiotics, prebiotics, adaptogens. Covers diet gaps, supports demanding life, healthy gut microbiome (impacts immunity, metabolism, hormones). Improves digestion, immunity, mood, mental focus.
New flavors: berry, citrus, tropical (Huberman likes berry, original with lemon). Special offer at drinkag1.com/huberman: 6 free AG1 travel packs, bottle of vitamin D3 K2, and 6 free sample packs of AGZ (AG1's new sleep formula—only sleep supplement Huberman takes, eliminates need for pills, best sleep ever).
Joovv makes medical-grade red light therapy devices. Light impacts biology profoundly (beyond sunlight). Red/near-infrared light: faster muscle recovery, skin health/wound healing, acne improvement, reduced pain/inflammation, mitochondrial function, vision.
Joovv uses clinically proven wavelengths for optimal cellular adaptations. Huberman uses whole-body panel 3-4x/week, handheld at home/travel. Exclusive discount up to $400 off at joovv.com/huberman.
Difficult to do what you want without imagining first. People fear outcome won't match hopes (fear of failure real).
Post-Activity Reflection for Learning and Retention
Episode on studying/learning maps to neuroplasticity. Recent literature shift: reflecting later accelerates learning, longer retention.
Learning is mostly anti-forgetting (massive sensory input, most forgotten as irrelevant).
Studies: reading passage multiple times, notes/highlighting/talking—best for retention: self-testing (reflect later: what do I remember? Correct errors) and reflecting (what happened, right/wrong?).
Like spaced repetition: reflection resurfaces material later, increases retention odds.
Huberman teaching experience: graduate/medical students motivated (high stakes, smaller classes, community, selection bias). Undergrads vary.
Most exposed to info, study for exam (next evaluation). Best students self-test or request pre-quiz—willing to feel pain of being wrong at low stakes (ego hit, but powerful).
Public scrutiny painful (Huberman/James examples of saying wrong thing/joke misinterpreted—now check everything).
James: slow learner, needs feedback. Places ideas online for public testing—unforgettable where works/doesn't.
Perfectionism vs Curiosity Mindset
Friend's perfectionism: if not best at something, talked self out of trying (anti-growth mindset).
James didn't, despite high desire to do right. Mindset: I can learn this—not comparison, but curiosity (trying new, learning from it). Less about competition (has place, James competitive), avoids talking self out.
Huberman: places self in venues (academic/physical) where can't be best—fuels competing outside institution, extra mile.
Jocko Willink (pre-Jocko writer): high stakes (wake early or people die). Maintains 4:30am wake-up (factory reset)—brutal (Huberman sauna story: Jocko gasping on floor).
Friction brings best, but can become painful (affects others). Rewards from relaxation too (Jocko saw show after sauna).
James good at shutting off. Josh Waitzkin example (Tim Ferriss podcast): asleep pre-martial arts event, woken 2 min before, did ritual, flipped switch.
Turn it on/off: sprint then rest. Fractal—10-year sprint (career-focused season), then family/relaxation; or day/week/hour.
Better balance: full on/off, not 50% steady state.
Physical (workout/rest), mental: e.g., hosting party (urgency/anxiety)—outside and above situation, feel larger than it (not smaller/driven by anxiety). Step outside/above for wiser/calmer decisions. Turn anxiety/stress on/off.
Reset underused—easy to carry work/comms everywhere. Huberman: social media on one phone (lockbox), phone-free hikes (worth risk: fire/mountain lions; reduces reaction time anyway).
Hard Work as Crutch; Need Reflection
Strong work ethic (worked out of problems) becomes crutch. Odds low that current work is highest/best use of time.
Sam Altman: high bar for working vs thinking what to work on (choosing right focus = 100-1000x results; 10% harder work not enough).
Executives/companies tapped out, heads down. Need step back/rest/reflect: right things?
James: 30 min Friday weekly review (nothing scheduled, think business)—best ideas emerge (should be 3 hours).
Carve time: directing energy/attention right way? Sprinting nonstop misses big picture.
Wordlessness: body/brain states awake, low info (work/anything). Liminal (awake-sleep), NSDR (yoga nidra), hiking/running/swimming/music.
Brain chatters then discontinuous.
James: after ~1hr hike—feels good (better than screen time). Forest bathing. Taps biological (humans as animals in forest).
Huberman: multivariable—full-spectrum sunlight, greenery reflects infrared light (cools leaves, penetrates skin, charges mitochondria; not damaging). Grounding (bare feet in stream; shoes block).
Primordial reset (trekking). James: Wednesday solo hikes, no phone/music—just woods. Becoming mountain man.
Return to real life. Reset huge for greatness (constant fight wears down).
Brings up identity (raised earlier).
One reason it's hard for people to relax, reset, or shift focus is how we catalog wins and losses. Many authors publish a book with partial success of Atomic Habits but feel pressure to repeat it or maintain buoyancy rather than internalize the win: "that was awesome." Atomic Habits is super impressive and successful for right reasons. Some can move on like Josh Waitzkin, a friend who cuts ties: "I'm done playing chess, doing the next thing." Most find it difficult, feeling need to succeed in same area or prior success feels unreal.
Habits, Identity, and Current Precipice
James Clear plays with habits and identity. Researched stories and felt personally:
- Military person after 20 years: "my identity was soldier, now who am I?"
- Athletes post-career: played through college (17 years for James), suddenly not an athlete: "who am I?"
- Founders selling company, long-term CEOs.
- Mother: "suddenly an empty nester, 25 years caring for kids, now what is my purpose?"
Key help: find through lines from past identity to new season.
- Soldier: not soldier, but good teammate, follows through on mission, reliable.
- Express past traits in current situation.
James emphasizes entrepreneur and creator over author (admits author due to book). Shift from blog to book to co-founding feels connected via entrepreneur story. Not abandoning past, but holding proud pieces into next chapter. Nothing lasts forever; be proud, carry pieces forward.
Contentment with Identity Shifts vs. Outside World Perception
James content understanding past, present, future. People tripped up wanting outside world understanding or hard cutting ties (e.g., Google "James Clear" says author).
Seen in professions: founders sell for $500M-$1B (Silicon Valley examples), feel postpartum depression days later—hunt over, unprepared catastrophic. Model for all experiences.
Titles powerful but double-edged. Most feedback on identity from others dangerous, holds in place.
Optimize for Playing the Game, Not Winning
Founder example: exit for large money, but true for anything. Optimize for continuing to play, not win (win = keep playing).
Glamorize outcomes, but ask: how do I want to spend my days? Draw box around desired daily life, maximize impact/money/people inside it.
People ask second question first (max impact/money), justify daily life outside box. Or optimize outcome (e.g., $500M sale) over lifestyle. Key: like how spend days, power over days, feel alive.
Requires different question than society asks.
Self-Identification Across Stages
Impressed by James' self-identification at work life stages (family too). Josh Waitzkin: grew as chess prodigy (movie about him), bricks to stay, but cut ties—never played again. Talks with affection and pain.
Transformative: starting family adds roles. Professionally/artistically/entrepreneurially, most hard breaking mold.
Jim Carrey: left Hollywood, highest-paid actor, most successful: "I solved it. I'm done." Beautiful.
No playbook; choose for self. Identity double-edged sword:
- Habits repeat, cast votes for desired identity, provides evidence, pride, fight to maintain.
- Long-run: tighter cling, harder to grow beyond.
Identity Hinders Growth When Clung To
Examples:
- Surgeon: 15 years one way, good outcomes, resists new tech, 5 years behind.
- Teacher: 20 years lesson plans, resists YouTube, behind curve.
- Stays on path too long.
Identity helpful early (establish habit, become that person). Like painting always retouched:
- Fixed parts: tall, father.
- Others fade, ebb, flow, change.
- E.g., never play chess again.
Willingness to reinvent, edit: life dynamic, not static.
Eight Sleep smart mattress covers: cooling, heating, sleep tracking.
Body temp drops 1-3° to fall/stay asleep, rises 1-3° to wake refreshed. Pod 5 (latest): Autopilot AI learns patterns, adjusts temp by sleep stage, elevates head if snoring.
Huberman used ~5 years, transformed sleep. Try at eightsleep.com/huberman ($350 off Pod 5), ships worldwide (Mexico, UAE).
Identity Relevance Across Life Stages
Relevant every stage deciding how to show up.
Neuroscience start: no field, textbook (Biological Psychology or Physiology?) pictured 5 luminaries with quotes. One: "I enjoy doing research more than eating." (Cooler than eating.)
Fun doing experiments, but danger: can't shift modes.
Recognition large (James) or small (community/family). Movie Basquiat about Jean-Michel Basquiat: conversation with friend on fame contaminating creative process (Guillermo del Toro talking, fun voice/content; link provided). Essence: known for not most important, or recognized wrong reasons → mismatch.
Big mistake: seeking to be understood your way, every level. Criticism hurts as misunderstanding genuineness/motivation.
Powerful: develop habits around own understanding of self/why there. Achieve milestones/feedback, but cognizant: doesn't change why did it. Take control of own thoughts/goal process or destroys.
Destroyed Basquiat (heroin addict, died AIDS/heroin overdose/both).
Destroys artists/entrepreneurs if not understood post-success.
Healthy Relationship to Atomic Habits Success
Atomic Habits: 25 million versions (readers' thoughts), no control. Accept it.
Highest-rated habits book ever, one of bestselling/top 100 selling books ever (7 years out), always on bestseller lists.
Trust good enough (not perfect, rewrite differently today). Fine if not ideal.
Adele on Someone Like You: "best song ever make behind me now" (depressing).
James: hard work, best effort, went well—fine, move on, not whole identity.
Healthy identity grows seasons: not fixated on others' thoughts. Worry not specific person, but collective imaginary 'they' in head—fictional, release fear.
Feedback, Personal Stories, and Failure
Healthy relationship to success/identity (earned). Happens small scale (2 people): serve better, want seen for effort and understood why (nice person). Grasping motivation understanding doesn't work—only when alone knowing truth for self.
Feedback: people map critique to head stories (family alcoholic, no success). Hard breaking through new environments (first to university/competitive sport).
Failure → story: "fated, family line fated" dangerous.
People never failed/trauma/difficulty most terrified/vulnerable. Known self-harmers/crashes: glowing examples creativity/performance/academics/sport first failure.
Learning to Fail Publicly Through Sports
Not just sports (public performance/risk failure). Sports taught public failure/rebound:
- Strike out ending game: terrible, move on.
- College gym: freshman weaker, miss set, next exercise.
Secret to winning: learning how to lose, bounce back, show up despite loss.
Senior season: "don't care, rather out there; if lose, my shoulders—I handle it."
Served entrepreneurship: keep reaching (not always win). Reach enough, works. Can't fear failure; know how to lose/come back.
Public Failure in Modern World
Powerful: willing publicly. Fan Twyla Tharp (choreographer): fail lot private, not public.
Now harder: mistakes on stage/court → phone/video/internet. Famous harder control reputation.
Inversion: textbooks showed best (MLK, sports stars). Now all unearthed.
Online scary middle/high school (dance: no phones, enjoy). Reputations/rumors/gossip/drama every level.
Stanford biology professor luminary: "it's all just like high"
He once said to me, "It's all just like high school forever." He insisted everything from high school forward is exactly the same: the way people interact, what they talk about, the drama, whispering—it never ends, baked into everything. Even in retirement homes, there's drama.
Twyla Tharp's statement: make a lot of mistakes in practice to perform excellently in public. When playing baseball or preparing for a big test, his dad said, "Trust your preparation." Two messages: relax, you're prepared; and prepare well with reps in private to perform in public. Durable truth: the person who prepares is in a better position to win.
Things are more public now, downside of rising profile: less space to experiment. Announcements are watched, so be thoughtful about designing experiment spaces, like kids without phones at dance recitals to practice without judgment. Still need lots of reps, but structure spaces carefully in modern society.
Be careful concluding what's the peak, like Adele's song. Also careful pursuing one peak after another. Books, music, poetry, art last forever—durable mediums.
Counterexample: media has high turnover. Legacy internet content: 2005 Steve Jobs Stanford commencement speech; many excellent TED talks; few scientific papers stand the test of time, replaced by field reviews.
Seeking legacy is dangerous; focus on constructing the day.
Never fail twice in a row: day-to-day attitude. Gretchen Rubin: split day into four quarters (morning, afternoon, evening, night). Lose first quarter? Win the next. Avoid thinking bad start ruins the day—reset.
Living a good life: have a good day even when things don't go your way, bounce back.
Never miss twice: encouragement after slip-up (e.g., diet binge on day 9, get back tomorrow; miss Monday article, post Thursday). Top performers make mistakes but rebound quickly. Fast reclaiming makes slip-up a blip; letting it slip for months is the problem. Course correct quickly.
Can apply within day for multi-time habits. Avoid optimization rigidity: missing optimal window doesn't mean over—have flexibility.
Intermittent fasting: same calories in 24 hours, different spacing (every hour vs. 6 hours vs. 8-hour window)—difference nominal? Exception: nocturnal schedule worse. Protect 1-3 hours before sleep: not hungry, low calories to avoid impeding sleep.
Night shift/computer at night bad for health (GI, cancer risk, longevity). Shift workers needed, but majority calories late bad.
Neurosurgeon at Neuralink (Elon's company): skips one traditional meal daily (breakfast+dinner, lunch+dinner, etc.), varies for flexibility—healthy.
Calories in/calories out and thermodynamics hold; avoid eating middle of night.
Instructive for habits: optimal robotic timing great if possible, but broad flexible range where doing it (even imperfect) > zero. Extremes harmful (e.g., 2am workout?). Flexibility key for sticking with habits.
Oliver Sacks (prolific neurologist/writer, squatted 525-600lbs, California squat record): photo writing outside train station on pen/paper seemed inspired. Actually, cramming between meetings—he was overscheduled, getting it in wherever.
Be careful interpreting schedules.
Regularity leads to entrainment (wake minute before alarm via operant conditioning of cortisol response—down to minute, even if set new time night before).
Battling to important work: better prepared 9-11am via entrained cortisol (not always bad—morning high needed for low night cortisol; flat curve bad). Can do afternoon, but entrainment helps lean into challenge.
Earlier in day > likely to happen (less interruption risk). Stack habits early.
24 hours, but varying control levels: find controllable hours (e.g., no kids? 7am meditation good; toddlers? No).
Circadian optimization for physical (e.g., workout 3 or 11 hours after waking).
Upstream habits: workout? Read (even 5min)? Write one sentence? (James Clear's pillars; reading/writing easier post-workout).
Workout ~10-11am after 7am wake: post-workout high/clarity, state change, energized.
Data: 3/11 hours post-wake ideal (body temp, circulation, morning cortisol rise—high morning cortisol quadrupled by exercise sets wavefront; needed high for low night).
Writing easier after reading: thoughts downstream from consumption (social media/podcasts/books/YouTube choose future thoughts—pick for better inputs).
Wrote online 14 years: rapid growth to 100k subscribers, then obsessed "must be really good," wrote more/read less—writing declined (fewer inputs/inspiration).
Analogy: reading = fill gas; writing = drive/adventure. Balance.
Relevant reading sparks unstoppable writing (2-3 pages in, riff).
Sequence (workout > read > write) = good day.
Like kid watching baseball then playing; not passive consumer.
Examples: Joni Mitchell painted before writing/singing; friend (musician/producer) draws early/midnight, then produces 50 years.
Load mind, pivot to creation (most stuck consuming; want to create but don't know how).
David Epstein's Range: broad exploration improves; experts T-shaped (broad top, narrow stem).
Top takeaway wrong—stem crucial precursor: focus/specialty/mission/project gives broad inputs something to latch (antenna for signals).
Creativity: rarely original thought; synthesis of unconnected things. Focus pulls/connects while reading widely.
James Clear discusses how immersion in a topic, like in graduate school (e.g., biology experiments followed by seminars and discussions), creates a pure environment saturated with related conversations. Online algorithms detect interests and feed content, but there's opportunity for self-selected filters to enrich feeds. He avoids low-value content on YouTube. Personal development content meshed with scientific literature appeals to him. Solution: be a selective forager; books allow direct choice unlike feeds. More control over content now exists.
Reading Preferences
Prefers physical books for first reads. Likes audio for travel or dense topics (audio prevents bogging down sentence-by-sentence, allows grasping overall argument). Rarely uses ebooks.
Note-Taking Method
In physical books: parentheses at start/end of striking passages, star in margin. Ends up with 30-50 starred pages. For relevant ones, photographs, highlights text on phone, copies into working doc.
"No input, no output." – Joe Strummer from the Clash.
Source and type of input matters. Summary: If you want to learn, wander. If you want to achieve, focus. Wandering surfaces new insights; focus channels them into productive outputs (music, research, book, business).
Function offers 100+ advanced lab tests for heart health, hormones, immune function, nutrients, toxins (BPA, PFAS). Analyzes results with doctor insights. Example: detected elevated mercury; advised limiting tuna, more leafy greens, N-acetylcysteine for glutathione/detox—second test confirmed success. Affordable, simple. Waitlist 250k+; early access at functionhealth.com/huberman. Huberman joined scientific advisory board.
Discusses cluttered laptop/phone screens as universes of distraction. Past: hat/hoodie, desk lamp blocked inputs. Now: strategies for desktop/internet productivity.
Never defined habit: academic view—automatic, non-conscious (tying shoes, brushing teeth). Alternative: behavior tied to context (e.g., Netflix on couch at 7pm pulls you in).
Clean Contexts for New Habits
Easier in clean context without battling old cues. Example: journaling on couch triggers TV. Solutions: dedicated journaling chair in corner—only journaling happens there.
Phone blends contexts (email, social, YouTube, games, scores)—like journaling on TV couch.
Clear's Phone Strategies
- 70-80% of time, leave phone in another room until lunch (9am-noon/11am). Prevents responding to others' agendas. If nearby, checks every 3min; if down hall (30s away), never fetches—reveals true desire.
- Friction curbs habits.
- For audiobooks: moved Audible to home screen, others to second screen—visual cue prompts desired action.
- Deleted social media from phone (1.5 years); uses desktop, assistant holds login/password—friction prevents casual use.
- Email off phone (6 months); downloads only if needed (twice: show tickets, airport email), then deletes.
Doesn't use Freedom/SelfControl long-term (tried during Atomic Habits writing; list grew unwieldy as research needed).
Not primarily dopamine-driven; more reflex/habit. Cues low-level/powerful (one picks up at dinner, others follow). Hard to lab-test. Discussion of dopamine rewards healthy, but phone use framed more as reward-seeking than reality (rarely memorable vs. salient real events like running into friend).
Social media as itch pathway scratched unconsciously.
Invert bad habits to build good:
- Obvious: phone always accessible/visible.
- Attractive: memes, games, notifications.
- Easy: frictionless (auto-swipe albums), convenience (DoorDash for eating).
- Satisfying: dopamine/reward.
Sticky because all four pulled—forms in 2-3 days effortlessly.
Invert four laws:
- Invisible: remove cues (no junk food home, unsubscribe emails).
- Unattractive: hardest (last resort; rewire via identity shift—e.g., book flips view of carbs/toast from breakfast to undesired).
- Difficult: add friction (sweets on highest garage shelf; cigarettes 3 miles away).
- Unsatisfying: immediate consequence (e.g., Brian's contract: trainer/wife; miss weight check-ins → wife gets $1000 shopping; hit → he gets $1000 football game).
More levers = better odds. Identity shift slow (2-4 years reinforcing new) or rare rapid switch.
Social constraints can play a big role. Years ago read article claiming many clinically obese people self-reported avoiding exercise because they felt it made
Social constraints can play a big role. An article claimed that many clinically obese people self-reported they didn't want to exercise because it made them feel selfish.
Now I'm sure some people hear that and they go, "Oh, they're making excuses." But it was interesting. Like let's assume that they were telling the truth because I think they were.
Most think of exercise as self-care to be around longer for others, but some view working out as selfish, self-indulgent, not kind or altruistic—time should be spent on others.
Fighting Environment vs. Flow
If you don't want to drink alcohol but went to a university where everyone drank, you're fighting an uphill battle. The way to win is to zig when they zag, take an antagonistic stance: "I'm not going to be like you." This separates you from people at social gatherings and is frustrating but effective.
Everyone else sleeps in, but you get up at 4 a.m.—"cuz I'm not like them." It works but is a separator. Building good habits while staying in context runs counter to surrounding yourself with good books, information, and people doing what you want.
Many live in landscapes where people go the wrong direction or aren't supportive.
The hard part is it's fight not flow. It's possible to fight your environment for a while, but it's hard to live that way for the long run.
Environment as Gravity
Environment is like gravity—physical and social. Physical environment nudges behaviors: sitting in this chair because it's there; using the door because it's easy, not breaking through walls (high friction).
All spaces nudge you toward easy, natural actions. Do physical spaces contribute to habits you're building? If yes, easier; if not, uphill battle.
Social environment is even stronger. If Atomic Habits had a sequel chapter, it'd be more on social environment (has a chapter on friends/family influence).
We're part of multiple groups (large like American/French norms; small like CrossFit gym, neighbors, school volunteers). Each has shared expectations, social norms, typical habits.
When habits align with group expectations, easy—praised, rewarded, welcomed. Against the grain: ostracized, criticized, judged. Humans are social creatures wanting to bond/connect.
People choose belonging (habits they don't love but fit in) over improvement (habits they want but ostracized).
For long run, align habits with belonging. Harsh ways: fire your friends. Better: find/create conducive spaces.
Live with non-yoga people but want yoga? Go to studio—surrounded by doers.
Key takeaway: Join (or create) groups where desired behavior is normal. Soak up behaviors, rise together.
Yoga studios are readymade. Others require creating: James cold-emailed 300 authors (30 responded), met at conference (10 there), hosted retreats (6-8 authors, Airbnb, 2-3 days on writing/launching books, audience-building). Always best weekends—everyone wants like-minded groups.
Creating Groups and Going Against Grain
Love creating groups if not available. Going against grain alone (e.g., exercise) is hard, but positive habits attract others asking how you did it.
Build what's not there—others will join.
Host's example: Scientific meetings—sit/eat/drink/sleep (unhealthy). Felt garbage, skipped sessions for workouts (talks not great). Ran into successful colleague (National Academy member) once: "If I sit all day, can't pay attention." Validation.
Stereotype: supposed to be at meeting, not exercising. People don't miss happy hour (caught colds). Professional contexts limit performance.
Communities change as people break out.
Midwest Upbringing and Family Habits
James: Born/raised Ohio, loves it, still lives there. Everything in Atomic Habits is teaching what parents taught, but publicly. Got lucky with good parents.
Dad: Professional baseball (minors, St. Louis Cardinals), insurance career.
Mom: Nurse, then cared for sister (leukemia at 3), later preschool assistant (high-needs kids like autism).
Both swim 5-6 a.m., diligent/reliable, like farmers (early risers). James picked up persistence from mom (finishes books), drive/competitiveness/outgoing warmth from dad.
Grandpa shaped mindset: PMA (Positive Mental Attitude). Emphasize good things, don't hold onto hardships, wary of martyrs (draining).
Habits with Kids
Kids young, but learn fast. Always teaching—even before words (e.g., reading built oldest's vocabulary).
Every moment is stimulus shaping mentally/physically. Movement specialist sat cross-legged perfect posture: everything is stimulus, whole day ongoing workout.
Key: Put in good positions/create conditions for success.
James: Good exercise habit 20 years, but tough with kids #2/#3. Hired trainer when #3 born—now never misses because trainer shows up, family respects it.
Problem wasn't workout, but conditions. Apply: writing book? Optimal writing conditions. Meditate? Seamless setup.
Host: Memories of parents' habits (dad's post-dinner walks/thinking; mom's/sister's). Habits are bedrock of life, entry to conscious time (e.g., phone pull-out leads to 30 min use).
Odds first-learned way is best? Unlikely.
Habits as Solutions to Recurring Problems
Habits (per Jason Rehea, behavioral scientist): solutions to recurring environmental problems.
Post-work exhaustion: run 30 min, video games 30 min, or cigarette—spectrum healthy/productive to not.
By 20-28, solutions inherited from parents/friends. Realization: yours may not be best—take ownership, find better solutions to same problems. No self-bate, just improve.
James Clear, thanks for teaching habit formation/breaking, exploring neuroscience. Huge fan of book/work.
Maybe just mention what you're most excited about now because
James Clear recommends reading Atomic Habits if not already done and incorporating its tools. He mentions an upcoming Atomic Habits workbook to operationalize the ideas: "How do I apply it to my actual life?" with exercises to fill out.
Atomic Habits Daily Calendar
- A page-a-day spiral-bound calendar with little mindset mantras and reminders on building habits, one per day.
- Provides a simple daily reminder, likened to a peak performance coach calling each morning at 8:00 a.m. for a 5-minute prime for the day.
- Not out yet, expected in a couple months.
- Host expresses excitement about the one-pager-per-day format.
I had this idea... what if I could hire like a peak performance coach? And all they did was they just called me each morning at like 8:00 a.m. and just gave me one like mindset thing... and then I go into the day and I'm like in the right frame of mind.
Host thanks James Clear for sharing tools and framework, emphasizes thinking about context and environment, and thoughts are downstream of inputs:
thoughts are downstream of inputs and really thinking hard about the inputs and controlling the inputs better because there's some great quality inputs out there and there's some less quality inputs. You are absolutely a high quality input.
Invites him back. Clear thanks for the opportunity.
- Subscribe to YouTube channel (zero-cost support).
- Follow on Spotify and Apple; leave up to five-star reviews and comments.
- Check sponsors mentioned at beginning and throughout.
- Questions/comments for Huberman Lab podcast: YouTube comment section (host reads all).
Andrew Huberman's New Book
- Protocols: An Operating Manual for the Human Body.
- First book, worked on for more than five years, based on 30+ years of research and experience.
- Covers protocols for sleep, exercise, stress control, focus, motivation, with scientific substantiation.
- Available for pre-sale at protocolsbook.com (links to vendors).
Social Media and Newsletter
- Follow Huberman Lab on Instagram, X, Threads, Facebook, LinkedIn for science and science-related tools (some overlap with podcast, much distinct).
- Neural Network Newsletter: zero-cost monthly; includes podcast summaries and protocols (1-3 page PDFs) on optimizing sleep, dopamine, deliberate cold exposure, foundational fitness (cardiovascular and resistance training).
- Sign up at hubermanlab.com (menu tab > newsletter); email not shared.
Thank you for interest in science.
Keep Andrew Huberman in your library
Save the videos and channels worth coming back to, and find them again in one place.
