Exercise Scientist Critiques Planet Fitness: Is It Really That Bad?
In a Nutshell
Planet Fitness built its brand on excluding serious lifters and compound movements like deadlifts, overhead presses, and T-bar rows to create a non-intimidating environment, but this approach lacked evidence that heavy lifters actually intimidate others. The gym's restrictions, lunk alarm, and "Pizza Monday" events directly contradicted effective training and nutrition goals. Recent additions of squat racks, deadlift platforms, and hip thrust benches show Planet Fitness is shifting toward real strength training as it recognizes members want actual results.
These notes were generated by AI and may contain inaccuracies.
Planet Fitness promotes itself as a gym where "everybody can work out in their own way" and explicitly states "We do not cater to bodybuilders or heavyweight lifters." The brand positions itself as the opposite of Gold's Gym, emphasizing a non-competitive, non-intimidating environment. The marketing explicitly welcomes "everyone" and promotes "Big fitness energy for all."
Planet Fitness has several explicit policies restricting certain exercises and behaviors. The gym requests members refrain from T-bar rows, overhead presses, clean and jerks, and deadlifts. Members are also asked not to perform supersets. The gym has a policy limiting members to loading only four weight plates on each side of machines.
Planet Fitness's approach stems from two competing perspectives. Every human being is entitled to prefer an unintimidating environment. However, the concern about intimidation from larger lifters lacks statistical backing - people being accosted or assaulted by jacked individuals in gyms is "unbelievably rare." The weights themselves pose no danger to other members since you're not lying underneath someone else's weights. The vast majority of jacked lifters are focused on themselves and their own training, not on intimidating others.
T-bar rows are banned primarily due to cultural associations - they attract a specific type of "jersey lifter bro" who tends to scream and create an intimidating atmosphere. Overhead presses are restricted despite being rarely performed due to their difficulty. Clean and jerks are prohibited, though the enforcement is questionable given that most Planet Fitness locations historically lacked barbells. Deadlifts are banned for the same reason as other compound movements - they're associated with big, burly, intimidating people. Supersetting is restricted because one person can monopolize multiple machines across the gym, creating conflict with other members.
Planet Fitness has a notorious lunk alarm that can be triggered by staff anytime they observe a member "working out too intensely." This includes behaviors like grunting, throwing weights, or otherwise appearing overly focused on lifting heavy weights. The policy aims to maintain the non-intimidating environment but has been criticized as overly restrictive.
The gym enforces a dress code prohibiting jeans, boots, sandals, and string tank tops. This policy targets the "jersey lifter bro" stereotype and aims to prevent members from throwing weights carelessly or intimidating others through their appearance.
Planet Fitness hosts Pizza Monday on the first Monday of every month, providing free pizza to members before, after, and during workouts. Bagel Tuesday follows the same concept on the second Tuesday of each month. While one slice of pizza won't destroy a month's worth of gym work, providing pizza at the gym creates a conflict with the fundamental purpose of gym attendance. These promotions have since been discontinued.
Planet Fitness offers the Beauty Angel total body enhancement chamber, a 12-minute standup booth combining red light therapy and whole body vibration. The equipment claims to work muscle groups, firm and tone the body, and reduce stress, though these claims lack substantial scientific backing.
Over 1,700 Planet Fitness clubs have introduced new strength equipment including squat racks, barbell racks, deadlift platforms, and battling ropes. This represents a significant shift from the gym's historical positioning. The introduction of hip thrust benches specifically caters to female members focusing on glute development. The gym appears to be recognizing that their market wants actual fitness results rather than just the appearance of working out.
Planet Fitness has evolved from being considered a "laughingstock" to becoming a more normal gym environment. The gym has reduced enforcement of restrictions against jacked individuals or grunting. The introduction of real weights and more serious training equipment indicates recognition that people want to train effectively rather than just pretend to work out.
Keep Renaissance Periodization in your library
Save the videos and channels worth coming back to, and find them again in one place.
