Back to All-In Podcast

GameStop CEO Ryan Cohen’s $56B Plan to Take Over eBay

All-In PodcastJune 23, 20261h 3m
Topics43
Opening Remarks on GameStop and Corporate Governance0:00Introduction and Background1:01Early Business Journey and Founding of Chewy1:30Business Model and Execution at Chewy4:00Consumer Experience and Customer Retention6:01Building and Selling Chewy7:31Transition to Activist Investing12:01Initial GameStop Investment13:01Identifying Value in GameStop15:31Board Appointment and 2021 Events18:01Strategic Pivot to Collectibles21:01Leadership and Talent Approach24:01GameStop Financial Performance26:30Motivation for Larger Acquisitions27:03Strategic Rationale for eBay Acquisition28:02Evaluating the eBay Opportunity29:24The Origin of the eBay Idea30:31eBay's Early Success and Subsequent Stagnation32:01Recent Performance Issues34:00eBay's Missed Opportunity with Stores34:30Amazon's Seller Margins and Market Opportunity36:31Marketplace Model Preference37:31eBay's History of Acquisitions and Divestitures38:00The Value of Focus38:30Post-Donahoe Era Performance40:00Seller Experience Problems41:30Management Approach Critique42:31Transition from Founder-Led to Professional Management44:00Three Strategic Priorities44:31Leveraging Physical Assets for Digital Growth47:02Digital Collectibles Market Opportunity49:30Board Rejection Rationale50:00Deal Structure Considerations51:32Shareholder Sentiment and Governance Issues54:00Media and Market Perception56:00CEO Meeting and Compensation58:00Market Function and Long-Term Value58:31Media Credibility and GameStop Narrative58:56The Meme Stock Narrative Lock-In59:31Hostile Takeover Strategy Discussion1:00:00Competing Bidders and Market Dynamics1:00:30Commitment to the Deal1:01:31Escalation Paths and Advisory Team1:02:00
In a Nutshell

Ryan Cohen is attempting a $56 billion takeover of eBay to combine it with GameStop's collectibles business, arguing eBay has stagnated under professional management with rising costs, flat revenue, and declining GMV despite massive e-commerce growth. He plans to cut $2 billion in operating expenses, expand live commerce using eBay's physical stores as fulfillment nodes, and build a digital collectibles marketplace for in-game items. Cohen is personally investing $500 million and states he will pursue any means necessary—including going hostile—since eBay management refuses to engage and has no skin in the game.

AI-Generated Notes

These notes were generated by AI and may contain inaccuracies.

Everyone hates GameStop and the media wants the company to fail. Board members make hundreds of thousands of dollars annually without buying stock with their own money and only attend a handful of meetings. Management is grossly overpaid. The speaker emphasizes that nothing is more American than risking your own capital and questions why everyone wants GameStop to fail.

Ryan Cohen joins the All-In Interview. The host notes it has been about a decade since their last dinner in New York. Cohen is currently attempting to acquire and run eBay, a significant story that connects back to the early days of the internet 25-30 years ago.

Cohen originally planned to launch an online jewelry website. He attended trade shows and purchased hundreds of thousands of dollars in inventory before building the website and distribution. While shopping at a neighborhood pet store with his poodle, he realized he understood pet products better. Key factors that attracted him to the pet category included:

  • Recurring revenue purchases
  • A still-fragmented market with neighborhood pet stores that Petco and PetSmart had not yet fully disrupted
  • Amazon had offered pet products since the 1990s but had not achieved significant scale in the category

The vision was to replicate the neighborhood pet store experience online at scale. Cohen studied Amazon's supply chain best practices including fast shipping, broad selection, and competitive pricing, while combining this with deep product knowledge from the pet store model. The entire team consisted of pet owners, creating genuine passion for the category.

Sign in to read the full notes

Get access to AI-generated notes, topic timestamps, and more.