Dividend ETFs vs Covered Call ETFs
In a Nutshell
Dividend ETFs distribute income from company cash flows and capture full upside participation, while covered-call ETFs sell volatility for higher yields but cap gains above strike prices. Covered-call funds perform best in flat or range-bound markets, whereas dividend funds tend to outperform in strong bull markets. Tax treatment also differs: qualified dividends often receive preferential rates, while covered-call distributions can be taxed as ordinary income or return of capital depending on the fund structure.
These notes were generated by AI and may contain inaccuracies.
If your goal is to generate income from an investment portfolio, you have likely come across two common categories: dividend exchange-traded funds (ETFs) and covered option funds. Covered option funds may show higher payout rates, but do higher payout rates automatically mean better long-term results? Not necessarily. In this video, we will compare how each strategy generates income, the areas where it is most beneficial, the tax considerations, and the investor objectives that each method may suit.
Dividend ETFs typically hold shares that pay dividends. Those profits are then distributed to the fund's shareholders. Many dividend funds focus on established companies, cash flow generation, and dividend consistency. Returns may come from both dividend income and long-term capital appreciation.
There are two main types of dividend strategies: dividend growth, which are companies with a consistent history of increasing dividends, and high dividend, which are companies that are vetted for financial soundness and have a history of paying relatively high dividends.
Dividend growth strategies and high dividend payouts, despite their tendency towards value, can differ in the composition of sectors. Therefore, it is important for investors to consider the context of their portfolio when choosing which dividend strategy to use. For example, high dividend funds tend to be more defensive than dividend growth funds.
Covered options funds seek to generate income in a different way. In addition to holding the shares, you sell call options against those holdings. The premiums collected on options may increase the portfolio's income distributions, and they come from a unique source: volatility. As market volatility increases, options generally become more valuable, which can lead to higher option premiums. Covered option funds seek to convert those premiums into income, rather than relying solely on cash flow from the underlying companies.
However, selling call options can reduce profit sharing during a strong market recovery. When a covered options fund sells call options, it receives premiums in exchange for giving another investor the right to buy its shares at a predetermined price. This premium can provide an additional source of income, but it may also limit participation in market gains if stock prices rise above the option's strike price. This is the essence of barter. Therefore, covered option funds may provide higher income potential by adding option premiums.
However, this potential for higher income often comes with a lower share in a strong market recovery because some of the earnings may be replaced by option premium income. Dividend funds generally maintain unlimited participation in profits. Therefore, when choosing between them, investors should evaluate current income needs, growth goals, and total return expectations. Higher income alone does not tell the whole story.
Dividend funds and covered option funds may behave differently depending on market conditions. Dividend funds may participate more fully in strong emerging markets. Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that employ a "covered call" strategy may hold up relatively better in stable or range-bound market environments, because option premiums can continue to generate income.
The tax treatment may also differ between the two types. Dividend funds may focus on qualifying distributions, which may receive preferential tax treatment compared to non-qualifying distributions. The income from Covered Call funds is treated differently from qualified distributions. In some cases, this may be more or less appropriate. Depending on the fund, those distributions may be ordinary income, a redemption of capital, or capital gains. Therefore, after-tax income may differ from declared distributions. Investors should consider the type of account, the tax bracket, and the distribution structure.
Investors can use both strategies. For some investors, the answer may be yes. Dividend funds and "covered call" funds can play complementary roles. One of them might focus on long-term growth and the quality of dividend payouts. While others may focus on a higher current income. Portfolio building ultimately depends on the investor's goals and risk tolerance. Therefore, although the two strategies are clearly different, they may work well together, depending on what the investor is trying to achieve.
In short, both dividend funds and "covered call" funds aim to generate portfolio income. But they do it in fundamentally different ways. Understanding the balance between income, growth potential, taxes, and market participation is essential when evaluating either strategy. Visit ishares.com to explore examples of both, and ask us any investment questions via Reddit at r/ishares.
Keep iShares by BlackRock in your library
Save the videos and channels worth coming back to, and find them again in one place.
