I Got My Body Fat Tested Every Way- Which Is Most Accurate?
In a Nutshell
A man with visible muscle definition tested eight body composition methods and found underwater weighing gave the lowest readings (3.2%), Bod Pod the next lowest (4.4%), and skinfold measurements varied widely by protocol (4.1–8.3%). BIA devices produced absurdly high results (20–33%), while DEXA scans had previously swung between 6% and 14%. His final estimate settled on 7–8% body fat, with high bone density likely skewing density-based methods downward; he recommends tracking waist circumference for progress rather than relying on any single absolute value.
These notes were generated by AI and may contain inaccuracies.
The testing was conducted at Cornerstone University in Michigan after previous DEXA scans produced inconsistent results, with one showing 14% body fat and another showing 6% body fat after a fat loss phase. The subject weighed 217 lbs on the day of testing and 222 lbs during the DEXA scan. The university has a well-equipped kinesiology lab with Dr. James Sackett, PhD leading the program. The goal was to compare all body composition testing methods except MRI.
The Bod Pod operates on a two-compartment model using body density calculations. It measures body volume by having the subject sit inside the chamber, then calculates density by combining volume with mass from weighing. The result was 4.4% body fat. The subject noted this seemed optimistic compared to the recent 6% DEXA result, though more accurate than the previous 14% reading.
The subject performed multiple underwater weighing trials, exhaling maximally before submerging and remaining still for 5 seconds. The platform scale measures weight underwater wirelessly. Results were 3.9%, 2.9%, and 3.4% body fat across trials, averaging approximately 3.2%. This method is considered the gold standard in research literature, though it showed the lowest body fat estimates.
Nine-site, seven-site, and three-site skinfold protocols were performed. The nine-site measurement yielded 5.9% body fat, the seven-site (most validated) gave 8.3%, and the three-site produced 4.13%. The seven-site method has the most research validation. Site selection affects results, with the seven-site excluding bicep and calf measurements, which were the subject's leanest areas.
Sign in to read the full notes
Get access to AI-generated notes, topic timestamps, and more.